Home

April 6, 2005
by Matt Barr

Misleading secrecy graphs

Matt Welch has an alarming graph showing that declassification of documents has fallen in every year of the Bush administration. He does not recall, I guess, having blogged about a presentation by Thomas Blanton, director of the National Security archive, just last month. Read about it here.

Blanton's presentation made it clear that declassification initiatives undertaken by President Clinton resulted in a huge spike in declassified pages, which, but for another spike when Bush took office, has been declining ever since. Which makes sense, since the executive orders signed by Clinton made millions of pages of material declassifiable for the first time, and you can only declassify them once. As I wrote last month, "In the years after the federal franchise was extended to women, 18-year-olds, D.C. residents, and so on, there was a spike of new voters, but sadly, that spike petered out after an election or two. Is that because election requirements were becoming more strict again?"

Someone in the comments alerts Welch to the numbers under Clinton, and he laments that Clinton's numbers trended downward, too. Well, no shit.

Browse books from Amazon.com:

Comments
Dave Himrich posted:

Plus you could look at the 2003 level (about 48M pages) and say that it is much higher than the typical level for the 80s and 90s. But then I suppose Welch would be all "But there are so many more pages that are candidates for declassification." And then I would be like "Convert it to a rate then, dumbass" and he would be like "Who's the famous libertarian blogger here, me or you?" and I would go "I think what you really mean is that you don't have any idea how many pages are available. Nice hat, by the way."

April 6, 2005 10:30 PM


Post a comment

Due to comment spam, please enter the five-digit security code along with your comment. I'm sorry for the hassle.

Terms of use/privacy policy (opens in new window)




Remember Me?

(HTML ok)

Enter this security code below along with your comment:




Home | Liberty | Written material © 2006 Matt Barr | Reproduce only with proper attribution |